Diversity and Other Religions

Dear Rabbi Fried,

Is it fair and right for God to let millions of innocent children get indoctrinated into false religions like Islam? Some of those children then believe they should become suicide bombers in the name of Allah. Why doesn’t God help prevent such tragedies by revealing himself more clearly to such people? I’m not asking the Jewish God to force people to believe in Him as their Father, just to give them clear evidence of it, similar to a DNA paternity test. One way he could do this, for example, is to line up all the stars to display the Shield of David, along with the 10 commandments for all to see. Also, He could communicate with people directly through regular mail, voicemail or even email, if he cared to. But it looks like this only happens in the movies like “Bruce Almighty”. Since most people are of different religions, it seems as if God does not care to develop a personal relationship with most of the planet! Is that right? Here’s another way of framing the same question: In monotheistic religions, God is regarded as the ultimate father figure. But what kind of father lets some of his children go their whole lives without ever learning His true name? Whether it’s Yah-weh, Christ, Allah or something else, God seems conspicuously silent.


Dear Jonathan,

Thanks for your penetrating questions which reflect much thought and introspection into core Jewish concepts. 

The world we live in is referred to, in Hebrew, as “olam hazeh”, or “this world”. The word for world, “olam”, comes from the root “alam” which means “hidden”. What does “the world” have to do with hidden?!

The answer, explain the sages, is that the Almighty “hides Himself” in this world. It doesn’t mean God is not present in the world. He is completely present but in a hidden way; one must seek Him out to find Him and create a personal relationship with Him. 

The reason God chose to be present in a hidden way is a very important one – to enable us to have free will. Free will is one of the very basic tenets of our belief system; without it man would be merely a type of robot, not be liable for reward or punishment for any of his deeds. There would be no room for Torah, for man to perfect himself and the world, for life itself as we know it. 

If God would make Himself present in a very obvious way, the choice between good and evil would not be an even or fair one. The option to do good would be overwhelmingly compelling; who could sin right before a revealed God?! This would reduce our choices to robotic ones. The same is true with respect to the Torah itself if the truths of Torah were clearly written across the Heavens for all to see. Although you are correct that this would not constitute physically forcing all to accept it and one could conceivably deny it anyway, the choice would not be even or fair. Only through the “olam”, by way of obfuscation of the existence of God and the Torah, do we have the opportunity for free will – and hence the reward endowed to those who seek out the truth and find it. 

One time, and one time only, did God see fit to reveal the truth of His existence and of Torah, by speaking directly to the Jewish people at Sinai in a way the entire world could hear. That one direct revelation to the entire nation, (which is accepted by Christians and Muslims as well – they just hold it was later changed), was meant to last throughout world history. 

Our job as a “light unto the nations”, and those nations as well, is to embrace the truths revealed openly at that time to all of mankind. That is our, and the entire world’s, free choice. If the leaders of certain sects choose to ignore the truth of Torah which teaches that life and love are supreme and choose instead a path of hatred and lauding death, that is their free choice. It is not God’s job, despite His love and best wishes for all of mankind, to miraculously set them straight. That would defy the purpose of creation.

Although we have seen why God will not reveal the truth to all as that would negate free will, your question partially remains unanswered; billions of people don’t totally seem to have free choice to accept the truths of Torah due to the rejection of their leaders or other situational reasons. This is a very difficult question which I have thought about for years, and to answer it, requires more thought…  


Rabbi Yerachmiel Fried

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

More To Explore

Jewish Law & Thought

Mourning After Kaddish

I have recently completed the year of mourning and kaddish for my father, and am left with a profound feeling of emptiness now that it’s finished. I know I can no longer say kaddish, but is there anything more that I can do or is that it?

Jewish History & Current Events


This time of the year, as I follow along with the readings of the weekly Torah portion, I have a lot of trouble studying the sections we are now reading that deal with the building of the Mishkan – tabernacle. First of all, I have a problem relating to it; how does a building they built thousands of years ago affect our lives. Secondly, why do these portions appear in the book of Exodus, which is the story of the Exodus from Egypt. Why are they not in the next book of Leviticus which deals with the sacrifices they brought in the tabernacle?